A Biblical Counseling Essay on Romans 1:20–21
Dr. Michael A. Scordato, Vertical Life Group — Biblical Counseling Essay Series
“For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse, because, although they knew God, they did not glorify Him as God, nor were thankful, but became futile in their thoughts, and their foolish hearts were darkened.”
— Romans 1:20–21 (NKJV)
PART ONE: THE ESSAY
1. “Look at the Colors”
I was walking my dog one morning, praying the way I usually pray on that route — carrying before God the people I love and the people I serve. In the middle of that ordinary walk, on an ordinary sunlit day, God said something to me that was almost embarrassingly simple. One phrase. Look at the colors.
So I stopped. Right where I was standing, I looked — really looked — at what was in front of me.
There was a cluster of flowers past their prime, and even in their fading I could pick out a pink-red at the center, ringed by light green leaves and darker green stems behind them, with a whitish purple bruising the edges of the petals that were already curling. Where the late sun could not reach, the shadows were not simply “dark” — they carried their own color, a blue-grey sliding toward black in the deepest folds. Above all of it, the sky was doing three or four different blues at once. And caught at the edge of my vision, one single leaf, already prematurely turned as if for autumn, hung there in a yellow-orange that none of the green around it was even attempting.
I kept walking, and I kept stopping. Every few yards, God said it again. Look at the colors. And every time I obeyed, there was more there than I had expected — not because the scenery changed, but because I kept looking past my first glance.
I want to invite you to do what I did. Not with your eyes on this page, but with your memory of any ordinary outdoor space you passed through today — your driveway, a parking lot, the walk from your car to your front door. Stop reading for a moment and reconstruct it. What colors were actually there? Not the two or three your brain filed under “green” and “gray” and moved past, but the specific colors — the variation within the green, the color hiding inside the shadow, the color you would have missed if you were moving at your normal pace instead of the pace of a man who had just been interrupted by God on a dog walk.
Most of us cannot do that exercise without slowing down first. That inability is the entire subject of this essay.
Partway through my walk, a verse settled onto my heart the way Scripture does when God intends to teach rather than merely remind: Romans 1:20. And then, almost as a follow-up instruction, I sensed Him say, Now contrast the two. In that instant, a memory I had not thought about in more than thirty years rose up in front of me, complete and specific, the way memories do when God is the One retrieving them.
2. Trained to See: The Lesson of the Preserved Fish
In high school biology, my teacher gave us an assignment that felt genuinely ridiculous at the time. Every week, for an entire unit, we had to sit in front of the same preserved, dead fish in a jar and write down what we saw. Ten minutes. No exceptions. No talking. Just look, and write.
The first week was easy, because there was almost nothing to it. I wrote down the obvious: it is stiff, it is pale, it smells like chemicals, it has a cloudy eye. I closed my notebook thinking I was finished — not just for the day, but for the semester. There is nothing else to see here. What am I supposed to write next week?
“Keep looking,” my teacher said, in the flat, immovable tone of someone who had heard that exact complaint every year for a decade and had no intention of being moved by it. He set the timer. Ten minutes. Mandatory.
By week two I sat down already defeated. I remember genuinely considering whether I could invent something — but he was far too attentive; he would have caught a fabrication in about four seconds. So instead of leaning down over the jar the way I had the first week, I stood up and looked from a different angle, almost out of boredom more than curiosity. And there it was: a perfect, overlapping grid of tiny scales I had not registered at all the first time, and a distinct lateral line running the length of the body that I could actually trace now that I was looking for it instead of just looking at it.
By week three I had a plan, which felt almost silly to admit to myself: look at it the way an artist would. And I saw it — the fins matched each other, left to right, down to the smallest bump and fray. Symmetry I had walked past twice already without noticing.
By week four I was finding folds inside the jaw, and pale pink gill combs tucked underneath the cover — structures so small and so hidden that I would have told you, honestly, in week one, that they did not exist.
Nothing about that fish changed across those four weeks. It was exactly, molecule for molecule, the same dead fish in the same jar of chemicals. What changed was my capacity to see it. I moved from a shallow, dismissive glance — I already know what is here, and it is nothing — to something closer to a masterpiece of intricate design, hiding in plain sight the entire time, waiting for eyes patient enough to find it.
3. The Spiritual Grayscale
Many of us walk through life — and many of us walk into a counselor’s office — looking at the world the way I looked at that fish in week one. We take a single, superficial glance at our circumstances, our pain, or even at God Himself, and we render our verdict in about four seconds: I already know what is here. It is cold. It is flat. It is empty.
We live, in other words, in a spiritual grayscale.
Picture, for a moment, what a genuinely colorless physical world would be like. In a world without color, everything bleeds toward the same dull shade of gray. Red berries and green leaves collapse into the same brightness, so the nourishment sitting directly in front of you disappears into the background. Predators dressed by nature in warning colors — the exact colors meant to say danger, stay back — blend seamlessly into rock and shadow, and you walk past the trap without ever perceiving it as a trap. You could stand and watch an actual sunset, in real time, and the flat, undifferentiated tones would stir nothing in you at all. No wonder. No ache. No worship.
Living in grayscale does not mean the color has been removed from the world. It means you have become functionally blind to color that is still there. That distinction is the entire argument of this essay — and it is also, I have found, the argument underneath an enormous amount of the pain that walks into a biblical counselor’s office.
4. The Canvas of Creation: Romans 1:20–21 in the Original Language
This is precisely the territory the Apostle Paul is standing on:
“For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse, because, although they knew God, they did not glorify Him as God, nor were thankful, but became futile in their thoughts, and their foolish hearts were darkened.”
— Romans 1:20–21 (NKJV)
Notice, first, what Paul does not say. He does not say God’s character is hidden, requiring some special decoder ring of philosophical sophistication to access. He says the opposite — and the Greek underneath the English makes the case even stronger.
“Clearly seen” translates kathoratai, a strengthened compound built on the ordinary verb “to see.” It does not describe a faint impression or a passing hint. It describes something so plainly, unmistakably visible that a person would have to work in order to miss it. Paul reaches for this precise word only this once in his entire body of writing — and this is the verse he saved it for.
“Being understood” translates nooumena, from noeō — the mind actively perceiving and grasping what is set in front of it. The tense matters: it is a present participle, ongoing action. Creation is not a museum piece that testified once, long ago, and has since gone silent. It is presently, continuously, right now — testifying.
“Godhead” translates theiotēs, the general quality or nature of deity displayed through what has been made. It is a slightly different word from theotēs in Colossians 2:9, which describes the fullness of deity dwelling bodily in Christ Himself. Paul is precise: creation does not reveal the fullness of who God is in His essence, but it reveals enough of His nature — His theiotēs — that no one can plead ignorance of it.
Which brings us to “without excuse” — anapologētous — a courtroom word. It means, literally, without a defense, without an apologia to offer. Paul is not describing a private feeling. He is describing a legal verdict. If a person were hauled before the ultimate court and asked to account for unbelief, the excuse “there was not enough evidence” would not be admitted, because the word Paul chooses has already established the opposite: the evidence was clear, and it was continuous, and it was perceived.
Verse 21 is where this essay’s actual thesis lives. “Although they knew God” — gnontes ton Theon — is not a description of ignorance. It is a description of suppressed knowledge. They knew. And then: “they did not glorify Him as God, nor were thankful.” Two failures, named in sequence — edoxasan, they glorified, withheld; and eucharistēsan, they gave thanks (the root of our word eucharist), withheld. Glory withheld, and gratitude withheld, in that order.
The result of withholding both is described in language that reads almost like a clinical diagnosis of what I have been calling grayscale vision: “they became futile in their thoughts” — emataioēsan, from mataios, empty, vain, like a container built to hold something and now holding nothing — “and their foolish hearts were darkened” — eskotisthē, was darkened, and asynetos, foolish, literally without synesis, without the capacity to put things together, to connect what is seen with what it means.
Read the sequence slowly and the mechanism becomes plain: suppression of known truth leads to the withholding of glory and gratitude, which leads to futile thinking, which leads to a darkened, disconnected heart. Paul is not describing people who lacked evidence. He is describing people who stopped saying thank you for the evidence they already had — and watched the color drain out of their own vision as a direct consequence.
God did not create a flat, mechanical, grayscale universe and then blame people for failing to see color that was never there. He flooded creation with the vivid, unmistakable “colors” of His own nature — His eternal power, His artistry, His faithfulness, His providence — precisely so that the case against unbelief would be, in Paul’s own word, unanswerable.
When a person tells me, in a counseling session, that they cannot see God — that He has gone silent, that He does not care, that He is not there — I no longer treat that statement as a report about the availability of evidence. Romans 1:20 has already closed that question. I treat it instead as a report about the condition of a pair of eyes. Like my own eyes in week one of biology class, they are rushing past the details, mistaking a shallow glance for a complete inventory, and calling the resulting gray a verdict on God rather than a verdict on their own unpracticed sight.
5. The Logic of Color: Cause and Effect in a Colorless World
I want to make this case as concretely and empirically as I can, because I think the strength of Paul’s argument in Romans 1 is precisely that it is not asking anyone to take a leap in the dark. It is asking them to notice what is already, demonstrably, in front of them. So let us reason through it the way we would reason through any cause-and-effect claim.
Color vision confers real, measurable advantages on the creature that has it. Strip color away, and each of those advantages fails in a predictable, traceable way. That is not a matter of religious sentiment; it is a matter of basic physiology — and it gives us a working model for what Paul is describing spiritually.
Survival and Safety. Color lets you spot ripe, red fruit against a field of green — take the color away, and red berries collapse into the same gray brightness as the leaves around them, and a source of nourishment sitting directly in front of you becomes invisible. Color lets you notice a venomous snake or a toxic insect that nature has, not accidentally, painted in warning tones — take the color away, and the warning blends into rock and soil, and the trap you were meant to see coming disappears. Color lets you read a health crisis on a person’s skin — a fever flush, a rash, a dangerous paleness — take the color away, and the early signal that something is wrong goes unnoticed until the problem is no longer early.
Mind and Mood. Color carries emotional information a gray world cannot transmit — the lift of a yellow sunrise, the calm of blue water — take the color away, and that entire emotional channel goes dark; the world becomes visually accurate and experientially flat. Color lets your eyes lock onto an object instantly by hue — your keys on a cluttered table, a single face in a crowd — take the color away, and your eyes are forced to search by shape and texture alone, one object at a time, and everything simply takes longer. Color organizes information — a traffic light, a hazard sign, a map — take the color away, and systems built to be read at a glance become systems that have to be puzzled out.
Every one of these is a cause-and-effect relationship you could test in a laboratory, and every one of them has a spiritual parallel you can test in your own life. The believer who has stopped noticing the “colors” of God’s provision does not stop being provided for — the provision, like the red berry against the green leaf, is still there, still real, still nourishing. What stops is the capacity to spot it quickly, to feel anything when looking at it, and to read it correctly as a signal rather than as noise. Romans 1:20 tells us the “color” of God’s nature was built into creation on purpose, the way color was built into the berry on purpose. Romans 1:21 tells us what happens to a person’s vision the moment they stop saying thank you for what they are looking at: the same cascade of failures — missed provision, undiscerned danger, dulled emotion, slow searching, misread signals — that a grayscale world would produce in the eye of any creature living in it.
6. Spiritual Color-Blindness in the Counseling Room
This grayscale-versus-color distinction has become one of the most useful diagnostic and pastoral tools I use in a counseling session, and I want to lay out exactly how I use it.
The presentation. People rarely arrive at a counselor’s office and announce, “I am suppressing the truth about God’s glory.” They arrive describing something closer to numbness. Life is flat. God feels absent. Prayer feels like talking into a closet. What they are describing, almost without exception, is functional color-blindness — not an absence of divine activity, but a loss of capacity to register it.
The cause-and-effect application. Romans 1:20 gives us the diagnostic starting point: the “color” was never withdrawn. God’s kindness, His justice, His power, His specific and particular care for the person sitting across from me are still woven into the ordinary fabric of their days — a friend’s phone call at the right moment, an unexpected provision, a body that still, mercifully, wakes up and works. Romans 1:21 gives us the mechanism of the fog: suppression of what is known, which shows up practically as a stop in glorifying and a stop in giving thanks, which produces futile thinking and a darkened, disconnected heart. The “grayscale” a counselee describes is not evidence that God removed the color. It is evidence that gratitude, at some identifiable point, went quiet.
The “without excuse” reality. If a person is standing directly in front of a vivid red rose and insisting it is gray, the correct diagnostic question is never “where did the color go?” The correct question is “what happened to your eyes?” Paul’s word — anapologētous, without excuse — tells us plainly that the failure of perception is not a failure of evidence. This is not a truth to wield as a bludgeon against a suffering counselee; it is a truth to hold out as hope. If the problem were a genuine absence of evidence, there would be nothing to do but wait and hope God shows up eventually. But if the problem is a pair of untrained eyes, then eyes — unlike God’s presence — can be retrained. That is a solvable problem, and solvable problems are where hope lives.
Counseling takeaways. Two practical movements follow directly from this. First, re-training the eyes: much of biblical counseling, practically speaking, is the patient, repeated discipline of pushing a person to stop rendering a four-second verdict on their circumstances and instead do the ten-minute, week-four version of looking — to keep looking after the first glance has already said, “there is nothing here.” Second, restoring gratitude: because Romans 1 traces the entire slide into darkness back to the moment glorifying and thanking stopped, the fastest on-ramp back toward light is often the most unglamorous discipline in Scripture — forcing yourself, out loud, to notice and name something you are thankful for. That single discipline, practiced with any consistency, is frequently the difference between a counselee who stays in the grayscale and one who begins, slowly, to see the reds and yellows and blues that were there all along.
7. The Cravings: When One Color Becomes an Idol
There is a specific and dangerous version of spiritual grayscale that deserves its own treatment, because I have watched it do more damage in counseling than almost anything else on this list. “I cannot hear God. I cannot see God” is one warning sign among many, but the particular form I want to name here is this: a person becomes convinced that God is only permitted to answer him — to love him, to prove Himself to him — through one single, predetermined channel. One method. One color. And if that specific answer does not arrive in that specific form, the person concludes, often with real anguish, that God does not love him, regardless of what else He may be doing.
This is not simply sad. It is dangerous, because it functions less like an opinion and more like a craving. The demand for the “one way” intensifies. The person’s ability to perceive anything outside that one narrow channel shrinks in direct proportion to how hard he is staring at it — until, not unlike a person in the grip of withdrawal, the absence of the specific thing he has fixated on produces real distress, and that distress looks for somewhere to land: on other people, or on God Himself.
I want to be careful and precise here, because Scripture is equally careful and precise: this craving does not describe reality accurately. God has not gone anywhere. He has not stopped loving the person or stopped supplying what he needs. What has happened is that the person has faded the color out of his own field of vision — narrowed the entire spectrum of how God moves down to one shade, then declared the world black-and-white when that one shade did not appear on schedule. He is still moving. He is simply moving in colors the person has stopped looking for.
Scripture is not silent about why this matters. He is good, and everything He does flows from that goodness — “You are good, and do good” (Psalm 119:68, NKJV). “For the LORD is good; His mercy is everlasting” (Psalm 100:5, NKJV) — not everlasting toward the one request currently consuming your attention, but toward all of it. “The LORD is good to all, and His tender mercies are over all His works” (Psalm 145:9, NKJV) — over the whole spectrum, not one shade of it. “O taste and see that the LORD is good,” the Psalmist invites (Psalm 34:8, NKJV) — an invitation to experience His goodness directly, not to negotiate for a single proof of it. He is “a stronghold in the day of trouble; and He knows those who trust in Him” (Nahum 1:7, NKJV), even when the trouble does not resolve on the timeline or in the shape that was demanded of Him. And every good gift comes down from a Father “with whom there is no variation or shadow of turning” (James 1:17, NKJV) — meaning the instability, wherever it shows up in this dynamic, is never on His end. Precisely because all of this is true, a good Father will not indefinitely feed a craving that has become unsafe for the child carrying it. Indulging the demand would not be love. It would simply be handing a person more of the very thing that is closing his eyes.
So: is He gone? No. He has not faded. The person has faded the color out of his own life, narrowing it down to black and white, no longer able to see Him at all — because He is moving in the color, in the whole spectrum of His character and provision, not only in the one occasional channel being demanded of Him.
The remedy is not more of the one color. It is recovering the whole spectrum — and specifically, recovering the one color the craving crowds out first and most completely: joy. “The joy of the LORD is your strength” (Nehemiah 8:10, NKJV) is not a throwaway line of encouragement. It is a diagnosis and a prescription in a single sentence. A person who has lost the joy of the Lord has lost the strength to keep looking past the first gray glance — and a person who recovers that joy typically finds, almost immediately, that the color was there the entire time.
8. A Practicum, and a Transition
Before we move into the counseling room, I want to leave you with the same assignment God gave me on that walk, because reading about color and practicing seeing it are two entirely different disciplines.
This week, find the color in the world actually around you — not metaphorically, but literally: stop somewhere ordinary, and make yourself catalogue every shade you can find, including the ones hiding in the shadows. Then do the harder version of the same exercise: catalogue every color of God’s provision in your own circumstances over the last month, the ways and means through which He communicated to you including the small ones, including the ones that did not come in the form you were hoping for. Say them out loud. And memorize Romans 1:20–21, so that the next time your own vision starts sliding toward gray, you have the actual words of Scripture on hand to interrupt it.
“For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse, because, although they knew God, they did not glorify Him as God, nor were thankful, but became futile in their thoughts, and their foolish hearts were darkened.”
— Romans 1:20–21 (NKJV)
What follows is a picture of what this practicum looks like when it is walked out, slowly and honestly, inside an actual counseling relationship. The case is a composite, and identifying details have been changed throughout to protect the people’s privacy (since multiple combined as one case); the substance of the struggle, and the way it broke, is faithful to what happened.
PART TWO: THE COUNSELING ROOM
A Case Study in Restoring the Joy of the Lord
The account below is a composite drawn from pastoral counseling experience. Names, occupations, and identifying details have been changed throughout to protect confidentiality.
Dramatis Personae
CHAPLAIN ANDREW VOSS — Biblical counselor. D.Min. in Biblical Counseling. Several years in pastoral and chaplaincy ministry, comfortable moving between direct confrontation and patient, wordless presence, depending on what the moment requires.
RAY DALTON — Age 46. Husband to Carol, father to two teenagers, including his son Jake. Twenty-one years with Meridian, a regional distribution company, laid off a month and half month ago in a corporate restructuring. Raised in church; describes his faith before the layoff as “solid, nothing fancy.” Referred to counseling by his pastor after Carol privately expressed concern that Ray had stopped praying except to argue with God, was sleeping four hours a night, and had told Jake, in anger, that God did not care about their family.
Setting: A small counseling room at the church, weekday evenings. Two weeks of sessions. What follows is drawn primarily from Session One.
Session Movement One — Opening: The Weight of the Layoff
[Ray arrives eleven minutes late, still in the polo shirt from a warehouse shift he picked up that afternoon. He sets his phone face-up on the table, screen already open to a job board. He does not look at Chaplain Voss when he sits down.]
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Ray. Thank you for coming. I know Tuesdays are hard to carve out right now.
RAY: Yeah, well. Carol set this up, so.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: I appreciate you honoring that, even if it wasn’t your idea. [A pause, gentle.] Before we get into any of it — when did you last eat something that wasn’t out of a vending machine?
RAY: [Slight defensiveness.] I eat.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: That’s not what I asked.
RAY: [A long breath.] …Yesterday, I think. Carol made dinner. I wasn’t really hungry.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: And sleep? Carol mentioned to Pastor Mills that you’ve been up most nights.
RAY: I can’t turn my brain off. I lie there running numbers. Mortgage, the truck payment, what happens if the severance runs out before something comes through.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: [Slides a bottle of water and a granola bar across the table, unhurried.] Eat that. Not because I think a granola bar fixes unemployment — because your brain cannot do the work this room requires on four hours of sleep and an empty stomach, and I’m not interested in wasting your evening pretending otherwise.
[Ray, after a beat, takes it. Unwraps it. Eats while Chaplain Voss waits without filling the silence.]
CHAPLAIN VOSS: I want you to know something before we talk about the layoff. You are not a project to me. You are not a problem I am here to solve efficiently and move on from. Whatever this season is doing to you, you are still the man Carol married and the father those two kids are watching right now — and that was true the day you got the call from HR (Human Resources), and it is true tonight.
RAY: [Quiet, a little thrown by this.] Okay.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Now. Tell me what happened.
[Ray describes the layoff — twenty-one years, escorted out with a cardboard box “like I was the one who did something wrong,” applications sent, two interviews, no offers, the severance clock running down.]
Elijah Method Applied — Physical Platform Before Diagnosis (1 Kings 19:4–8)
Before a single theological question is asked, Chaplain Voss assesses Ray’s sleep and nutrition and meets both, however small the gesture. This is not stalling; it is sequence. God fed Elijah before asking him a single question in the wilderness. A man running on four hours of sleep and a vending machine cannot do the reflective work this counseling relationship will eventually require of him. The James Architecture opens alongside it — the counselor names Ray’s worth (“you’re still the man Carol married”) before a single deficit is discussed, following the James 1:1 pattern of blessing before diagnosis.
Session Movement Two — Naming the Craving
CHAPLAIN VOSS: When you pray about the job search — and I’m assuming you still are — what are you actually asking God for?
RAY: [Flat.] For Meridian to call me back.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Meridian. Your old company.
RAY: They laid off eleven of us. Two have already been quietly brought back on contract. I keep thinking — I gave them twenty-one years. If anybody deserves the call, it’s me. So yeah. I’m praying Meridian calls.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: And if a different company called first — a good job, comparable pay — would that count as an answer to your prayer?
RAY: [Pause. This clearly has not occurred to him as a real question.] I mean… it’d be a job.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: That’s not what I asked.
RAY: [Frustrated.] What do you want me to say? I want Meridian. I want them to admit they were wrong to let me go. Anything else just feels like — like a consolation prize. Like God’s telling me to settle.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: So if God provides for your family through any door except that one specific door, it doesn’t register to you as God providing.
[Silence. Long enough that it becomes an answer.]
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Ray — who told you God was only allowed to answer you through Meridian?
RAY: Nobody told me that. That’s just… that’s the one that would actually fix this.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Fix what, exactly? The bills, or the twenty-one years that feel like they were thrown away?
RAY: [Quiet, and this lands somewhere real.] …Both, I guess. Mostly the second one.
Metanoia Confrontation — Exposing the Single-Channel Craving
Chaplain Voss does not challenge the legitimacy of Ray’s desire for Meridian to call; he challenges the framework that has quietly attached Ray’s entire perception of God’s love to that one outcome. This is a gentle disruption of the deeply embedded belief that God’s love can be measured on a single gauge. Ray’s honest answer — that the real wound is the twenty-one years, not merely the bills — surfaces the actual grief underneath the craving, which must be named before the Color Method in Movement Three can do its work.
Session Movement Three — The Color Exercise
CHAPLAIN VOSS: I want to tell you about a walk I took with my dog a while back. [Recounts, briefly, the “look at the colors” experience and Romans 1:20.] … The point is, none of that color went anywhere. I just wasn’t looking closely enough to see it.
RAY: Okay, but this isn’t a walk. This is my mortgage.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Fair. So let’s do the exercise with your mortgage instead of my flowers. I want you to catalogue every color of provision God has moved through in the last month — every single one, no matter how small, no matter how far from “Meridian calls” it is. I’ll write them down.
RAY: [Reluctant, but starts.] …Carol picked up extra hours at the clinic. That’s kept us current on the mortgage. Barely.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: That’s one. Keep going.
RAY: Tom — my old shift lead — mentioned a logistics coordinator opening at Bishop Freight. I haven’t followed up.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Two. Why haven’t you followed up?
RAY: [Uncomfortable.] It’s not Meridian.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Noted. Keep going.
RAY: [A longer pause, like he is actually searching now instead of resisting.] Jake — my son — he’s been mowing Mr. Halvorsen’s lawn for cash since July. Gave me sixty bucks two weeks ago. Didn’t ask him to. Just… put it on the counter.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: [Lets that sit for a second.] Three.
RAY: The church brought over three dinners the week the severance math got bad. I didn’t ask for that either.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Four.
RAY: [Quieter now.] Sunday before last — I don’t know how to explain this — I was sitting in the back, not even really listening, and out of nowhere I wasn’t panicking for about ten minutes. First time in months.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: That’s not a small one, Ray. That’s five. Peace that doesn’t come from your circumstances changing — that’s still provision. It’s just not the kind you can deposit in a bank.
RAY: [Looking at the list Chaplain Voss has written out — five items, in Ray’s own words. Something in his face shifts, almost against his will.] I hadn’t… I wasn’t counting any of that as anything. It just felt like noise while I was waiting for the actual answer.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Ray, look at that list again. None of it is Meridian. All of it is real. Romans 1:20 says God’s provision is “clearly seen” — not hidden, not subtle, not requiring a decoder ring. You had five specific, visible, undeniable colors on the table before you walked in here tonight, and you’d filed every one of them under ‘not the answer’ because none of them was the one shade you had decided in advance you were owed.
The Color Method Applied — Cataloguing the Clearly Seen (Romans 1:20)
This is the counseling technique introduced in Part One of this essay: the deliberate, out-loud cataloguing of every visible evidence of God’s character and provision in the counselee’s immediate circumstances. The method has two movements — first, an honest inventory of what has actually happened, not what the counselee wished had happened; second, naming each item as a legitimate “color” rather than a consolation prize. Ray’s own resistance to including Tom’s job lead (“It’s not Meridian”) is instructive: it shows the single-channel craving actively filtering evidence in real time, exactly as Romans 1:21 describes. The exercise does not argue Ray out of his grief over Meridian. It simply places, beside that grief, five things that were true and visible and that he had stopped counting.
Session Movement Four — The Diagnosis of Romans 1:21
CHAPLAIN VOSS: I want to read you something, and I want you to just listen before you respond. [Reads Romans 1:21, NKJV, aloud.] “Although they knew God, they did not glorify Him as God, nor were thankful, but became futile in their thoughts, and their foolish hearts were darkened.”
RAY: [Bristling slightly.] Are you saying this is my fault? That I did this to myself?
CHAPLAIN VOSS: I’m saying something a little different, and I want to be precise, because the difference matters. I don’t think God stopped providing for your family in April. I think somewhere around week two, you stopped saying thank you for what He was still doing — and the moment the thanking stopped, so did your ability to see it. That’s not a flaw unique to you, Ray. Paul says it happens to everyone who stops looking. It has happened to me. It is happening right now to half the congregation on a Sunday morning. You are not uniquely broken. You are describing the most common spiritual condition in the human race.
RAY: [Silent, working through this.]
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Can I tell you a short story?
RAY: [Wary.] Go ahead.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: There was a man who owned two fields. One field he had never had to work very hard for — a spring fed it that he had not dug, rain fell on it whether he asked or not, and for years his neighbors had quietly helped him tend it without him ever really noticing who had done what. The other field belonged to somebody else. It was not for sale. But it was the one he had set his heart on, and every single day he walked past his own green, well-watered field, straight to the fence line of the field he did not own, and stood there. Day after day. Insisting he was starving. And the field behind him — the one that was actually his, the one that had never once stopped producing — went to weed, because he would not turn around and look at it.
RAY: [A long silence. When he speaks, his voice is not defensive anymore.] That’s… that’s the mortgage. That’s Carol’s extra shift. That’s Jake’s sixty bucks. [He looks up.] That’s me, standing at Meridian’s fence every single day.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: [Quietly.] Yes.
RAY: [His composure breaks, just slightly — not dramatically, but real.] I’ve been telling God for one and a half months that He doesn’t love me. I said it to my own son. [His voice catches.] And this whole time there’s been a field behind me.
Nathan Principle Applied — Story as Scalpel (2 Samuel 12:7)
Chaplain Voss does not open this movement by accusing Ray of ingratitude; he opens it by reading Scripture and then telling an original parable structurally identical to Nathan’s confrontation of David — a story about someone else’s misplaced fixation that Ray is left to apply to himself. Ray’s identification (“That’s me, standing at Meridian’s fence”) arrives before any direct application is offered. The confrontation lands because the story did the work first; the directness that follows is received rather than resisted, consistent with the pattern seen throughout Scripture wherever the Parable Method and the Prophet’s Method operate in sequence.
Session Movement Five — Discovering the Joy of the Lord
CHAPLAIN VOSS: Ray, I want to ask you something, and I want an honest answer — not the answer you think a Christian is supposed to give in a chaplain’s office.
RAY: Okay.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: When was the last time you felt anything like joy?
RAY: [A long pause. Genuinely searching.] I don’t… I don’t know. Before April, I guess. It’s not just that I’m sad. It’s like I can’t access it anymore. Even good moments — Jake handing me that sixty bucks — I noticed it, but I didn’t feel it. Not really.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: That’s the actual diagnosis, Ray. Not unemployment. Not even the anger at God, though we will keep dealing with that. You have lost the joy of the Lord. And Nehemiah 8:10 does not call that a minor spiritual inconvenience — it calls joy your strength. ‘Do not sorrow, for the joy of the LORD is your strength.’ You haven’t just been unemployed for about one and a half months. You’ve been running on empty for this month plus, because the one thing Scripture says actually fuels you, you stopped drawing on the day you stopped saying thank you.
RAY: [Quietly, almost to himself.] I’ve been cursing Him. Not — not out loud in church. But in my truck. At night. I’ve told Him exactly what I think of Him not showing up.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: [No shock, no lecture — steady.] I know. And I’m not going to pretend that’s a small thing, or rush you past it with a Bible verse. But I want you to hear this clearly: the door back is not more evidence. You have never actually lacked evidence — we found five pieces of it in twenty minutes tonight, and there were more we didn’t have time to name. The door back is thanksgiving. James 1:2–4 does not ask you to feel joyful about the layoff. It asks you to count — actively, deliberately, sometimes through gritted teeth — what the trial is producing, and to keep counting until counting becomes a discipline instead of a performance.
RAY: [He picks the list back up — the five items from Movement Three — and reads it again, silently this time.] Carol. Tom’s lead. Jake’s sixty dollars. The dinners. The ten minutes of peace on Sunday. [He looks up.] I want to say thank You for these. Out loud. Right now, if that’s okay.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: It’s more than okay. Go ahead.
[Ray reads the list aloud, slowly, and thanks God for each item by name. His voice is unsteady through the first two and steadier by the fifth. Chaplain Voss does not interrupt.]
CHAPLAIN VOSS: How do you feel?
RAY: [A long breath out, like something has actually released.] Lighter. Not fixed. I still don’t have a job. But… lighter.
CHAPLAIN VOSS: That’s the color coming back, Ray. Not because your circumstances changed tonight. Because your eyes did.
Nehemiah 8:10 and James 1:2–4 Applied — The Named Destination
The session closes not with a plan for the job search but with a named destination: joy, specifically identified as the missing “color” underneath every other symptom Ray brought into the room. The reversal of Romans 1:21 is enacted rather than merely explained — Ray glorifies and gives thanks aloud, in real time, reversing the exact two failures Paul names as the origin of the darkened heart. This is the casting of care made concrete (1 Peter 5:6–9), arriving at the passage this entire case study has been building toward: ‘the joy of the LORD is your strength.’
Post-Session Synthesis
The markers of genuine change in Ray over the following weeks were not dramatic. He did not receive a call from Meridian. He did, in the third week after this session, follow up on Tom’s lead at Bishop Freight — the door he had been filtering out as “not the answer” — and was offered a position there five weeks later, at comparable pay, doing work he ended up describing as “closer to what I actually wanted to do anyway.” That detail matters less as a happy ending than as a confirmation of this essay’s thesis: God had not been withholding provision from Ray for these months. Ray had been withholding his sight from the provision that was already in motion, and the offer, when it came, arrived through a color he had already been shown once and had already, once, refused to look at.
What changed first — weeks before any job offer — was smaller and more durable. Ray began naming provision unprompted, without being asked to catalogue it in a session. He apologized to Jake for what he had said. He resumed praying in a form that had stopped sounding like a transaction and started sounding, in his own words, “like actually talking to somebody instead of filing a complaint.” None of that was manufactured for the counselor’s benefit. It was the quiet, unglamorous evidence of hupomonē — remaining under the load rather than running from it — and it began the night Ray chose to say thank you for a field he had been standing with his back to for months unemployed.
Classroom Discussion Questions
1. Chaplain Voss assesses Ray’s sleep and nutrition before discussing the layoff at all. Why is this sequence — and not merely this content — theologically significant, and how does 1 Kings 19:4–8 ground it?
2. Ray’s craving for one specific answer (Meridian) is treated as a diagnostic category in its own right, distinct from the layoff itself. What distinguishes a legitimate desire from what this essay calls a “single-channel craving”?
3. The Color Method asks a counselee to catalogue evidence rather than simply reassuring him that God loves him. Why might an inventory be more effective, pastorally, than a direct assurance?
4. Identify the moment in Movement Two where Ray’s own words reveal the craving filtering evidence in real time (“It’s not Meridian”). How would you help a counselee notice this pattern in himself outside a counseling session?
5. Compare the invented parable in Movement Four to Nathan’s confrontation of David in 2 Samuel 12. What made Ray’s identification with the story arrive before, rather than after, the direct application?
6. The essay argues that joy, not information, was Ray’s actual deficit. What is the practical difference, in a counseling relationship, between giving a counselee more evidence of God’s care and helping him recover the capacity to feel joy over evidence he already has?
Closing Scripture
“Then he said to them, ‘Go your way, eat the fat, drink the sweet, and send portions to those for whom nothing is prepared; for this day is holy to our Lord. Do not sorrow, for the joy of the LORD is your strength.’”
— Nehemiah 8:10 (NKJV)
“My brethren, count it all joy when you fall into various trials, knowing that the testing of your faith produces patience. But let patience have its perfect work, that you may be perfect and complete, lacking nothing.”
— James 1:2–4 (NKJV)
“For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse.”
— Romans 1:20 (NKJV)
To continue on further into this concept read…
